Book Reviews

The Laws of Medicine By Siddhartha Mukherjee

March 25, 2016

|

Reviewed by Jill Ladwig, Thinklabs

 

The Laws of Medicine is a slim volume that eloquently reveals any “laws” that exist in medicine are dynamic, and that the field is ruled more by instinct than by rules.

 

Written by the Pulitzer Prize-winning author of The Emperor of All Maladies: A Biography of Cancer, the book is packed with elegant prose about the vagaries of medicine.  Based on a TED Talk of the same name, The Laws of Medicine shows the relative lawlessness of a field whose “rules” are built on shifting sand.  

 

The author admits that he spent much of his residency on a quest to discover such “laws” so that he could succeed.  He writes that he imagined the “rules a young doctor might teach himself to navigate a profession that seems, at first glance, overwhelmingly unnavigable.”

 

Though his compulsion to discover an infallible source of direction is understandable, the young doctor’s search proves fruitless.  Mukherjee determines his own practical guidelines, and outlines these in the book.  For example, take Law One: A strong intuition is more powerful than a weak test.   

 

Mukherjee relays a medical mystery to prove his case: a 56-year-old patient who lives in a wealthy neighborhood in Boston, dresses like a banker, suddenly experiences dramatic weight loss and muscle weakness.  After thoroughly looking for the obvious culprit--cancer-- the myriad tests come back negative.  

 

It’s only after the doctor finally sees the patient out of context does he suspect that he may be a drug addict infected with HIV, which turns out to be true. “A first test can only be interpreted sanely in the context of prior probabilities.”

 

“It seems a rule taken from a Groucho Marx handbook: you need to have a glimpse of an answer before you have a glimpse of an answer,” he writes.

 

Further, Mukherjee emphasizes the importance of the patient history as a critical piece of any diagnosis.  To underscore this ideal, he presents “Law Three:  For every perfect medical experiment, there is a perfect human bias.”  

 

Every test, he writes, should be backed up by the patient history, the physical examination, and the doctor’s experience and instinct.  As an example of a pervasive bias, he cites the radical mastectomy to cure breast cancer.  Surgeon William Halsted pioneered the radical mastectomy in the early 1900s as a response to the frequent re-emergence of cancer in other parts of the body after surgery.  He believed these recurrences to be the result of “unclean” operations, which led him to try a different, more aggressive approach.  By amputating the breast and all the surrounding tissue up to the armpit, he reasoned, he was literally pulling the cancer out of the body by its roots.

 

He called the surgery “radical,” using a term from Latin that means to pull out by the root.  As the surgery became increasingly popular, the word “radical” lost its original meaning. Halsted’s students and patients began to think of “radical” in its second meaning: brazen or bold.  Over time, Mukherjee writes, “the word itself metastasized,” thus becoming one of the “most inscrutable forms of bias.”   

 

Who wouldn’t want to take a radical approach against killer cancer?  But Mukherjee says in the case of breast cancer, this bias led to the overuse of a traumatic surgery that could easily have been avoided by many women. But it was the most common way to treat cancer for more than 85 years.


“Every science suffers from human biases,” Mukherjee says. In medicine, these biases are particularly acute.  The Laws of Medicine gives readers an insight into the medical anomalies that are replete in a constantly evolving field, and the importance of the gut instinct in the minefield of medicine.

Please reload

Nursing Runs in the Family

May 6, 2019

Simon’s Heart Beats On: Foundation Screens Young Athletes for Sudden Cardiac Arrest

November 7, 2018

Being the Ears for a Young ENT

February 27, 2017

Therapist Uses Thinklabs One to Create Gifts for Grieving Families

October 24, 2016

Thinklabs and SIU Connect Patients to Doctors in Rural Illinois

August 17, 2016

The Finest Traditions of My Calling by Abraham Nussbaum

June 20, 2016

Recreating the Rhythms of the Womb

April 21, 2016

The Laws of Medicine By Siddhartha Mukherjee

March 25, 2016

When Doctors Don’t Listen: How to Avoid Misdiagnoses and Unnecessary Tests

March 25, 2016

When Breath Becomes Air

March 18, 2016

Please reload

Recent Posts

Nursing Runs in the Family

May 6, 2019

1/1
Please reload

Featured Posts
Follow Us

ICU

SCA

amplified

cardiac screening

digital stethoscope

long QT

nurse

stethoscope

telemedicine

Please reload

Search By Tags

May 2019 (1)

November 2018 (1)

February 2017 (1)

October 2016 (1)

August 2016 (1)

June 2016 (1)

April 2016 (1)

March 2016 (4)

April 2015 (1)

October 2011 (3)

August 2011 (1)

March 2011 (3)

February 2011 (4)

January 2011 (1)

October 2010 (1)

June 2010 (1)

May 2010 (3)

October 2009 (1)

September 2009 (2)

July 2009 (3)

June 2009 (2)

April 2009 (3)

March 2009 (6)

January 2008 (1)

September 2007 (1)

August 2007 (3)

July 2007 (2)

June 2007 (3)

May 2007 (1)

January 2007 (8)

December 2006 (4)

November 2006 (3)

October 2006 (1)

Please reload

Archive
  • Facebook Basic Square
  • Twitter Basic Square
  • Google+ Basic Square

One

Digital Stethoscope

Stay in Touch  |  About  |  FAQ  | Contact Us  | Register your One | Support

  • Wix Facebook page
  • Wix Twitter page
  • Instagram

Thinklabs Store

Store

  • Wix Facebook page
  • Wix Twitter page
  • Instagram

Contact Us

Buy Now

Support & Service

FAQ

About Us

Thinklabs in the News & Published Research

Thinking Out Loud - Blog

Engineering Library - Manuals & Downloads

Copyright 2003-2020 - Thinklabs Medical LLC

Thinklabs and the Thinklabs logo are

registered trademarks.

 

Photo Credits:

Science and Society - Laennec Stethoscope

NASA - Earth Images

Beats, Monster, Bose - headphones

Sound Library - Heart & Lung Sounds

Law Library - Warranties, Return Policy, etc.

  • ONE DIGITAL STETHOSCOPE

  • COVID-19

  • Apps

  • Clinical Application

  • How-To Video

  • Sound Library

  • ds32

  • Blog

  • More